If you are interested in information on what it is like being a tenant at Pompton Plaza at 200 Wanaque Ave Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442 (The Pompton Plaza Building), feel free to email us at 200wanaque07442@gmail.com.

As a former tenant of over 5 years, we are able to share our honest feedback regarding the building, it's condition, maintenance and more as well as our experience regarding the landlords and other information and insights that may help you understand what it would be like to lease space in this building, how you will be treated as a tenant and what you may encounter at the end of your lease in regards to your security deposit and more.

11/1/25 - We had ended our lease on 8/31/25 and the landlords have refused to provide back our security deposit, claiming documented damage, pre-existing before the start date of our lease, was the result of our tenancy. 

Preexisting damage including unpainted spackle on the walls, stained carpets and more, which have time and location stamped photos showing as preexisting prior to the start of the lease.

The Landlord's are also claiming that unoccupied space that they allowed us to use to store our items at no charge, as a result of the continual leaks of biohazard material from the common area bathrooms above (yes, we are talking about 💩POOP💩 and other bodily waste) and have assigned a value (with no agreement) to it that is greater than the amount of the security deposit and are using that as a means to dispute the return of the security deposit.

Throughout the tenancy, there have been several instances of plumbing failures, most specifically and commonly due to the common area bathrooms. On many occasions the pipes in those bathrooms had become clogged and backup up causing fecal matter, urine and other bathroom waste water to DRIP THROUGH THE FLOOR into the occupied office space causing damage to office equipment, inventory, personal items, loss off business and turmoil to the personnel.

The Landlords wanted to put up signs in the common area bathrooms telling people NOT TO FLUSH their toilet paper down the toilets and instead to put them in a wastebin next to the toilet. 🤦‍♂️

Should a resolution not be reached shortly, all legal remedies will be pursued.

It is our honest and truthful opinion that anyone who is considering becoming a tenant in 200 Wanaque Ave Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442 (The Pompton Plaza Building - a.k.a. POOP-TON PLAZA ) take into serious account the aforementioned facts regarding the building condition and landlords' actions.

200 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes NJ 07442 – Pompton Plaza

Welcome to 200 Wanaque Avenue in downtown Pompton Lakes, New Jersey. This location, also known as Pompton Plaza, is home to businesses like Escape Room NJ, Rage Room, Hug-a-Mug Café, Cardinal Athletics, and Kids Rule Parties. Conveniently located near Route 23 and I-287, the plaza offers free parking, walkability, and easy access to downtown Pompton Lakes.

Businesses Located at 200 Wanaque Ave

• Escape Room NJ – immersive puzzle & team-building experiences

• Rage Room – safe smash-and-destroy fun in private rooms

• Hug-a-Mug – cozy local café

• Cardinal Athletics – youth sports training and fitness

• Kids Rule Parties – children’s birthday & event hosting

Historical Snapshot

Pompton Lakes traces its origins to the late 1600s and achieved borough status in 1895. It became an industrial center with ironworks powering multiple wars and even witnessed innovations like early regenerative liquid-fuel rocket cooling systems in the 1930s A local family-run department store, Gelman’s, flourished at this address for several decades, leaving a lasting mark on community memory. Additionally, the borough’s rivers, lakes, and small-town charm continue to draw visitors—just 20 miles from Manhattan.

Former and Current Tenants

• Gelman’s Department Store – A beloved family-run business from early last century to the late 1970s :

• Current tenants: Escape Room NJ, Rage Room, Hug-a-Mug, Cardinal Athletics, Kids Rule Parties.

Nearby Attractions

Located in the heart of Pompton Lakes, visitors can enjoy Rotary Park, Hershfield Park, Pompton Lake, and the Pompton Aquatic Park. The area is walkable, safe, and part of a lively small-town community just 20 miles from Manhattan.

Office & Retail Space for Lease

Pompton Plaza offers a range of office and retail suites for rent:

• Suite 303 – 550 sf, move-in ready office

• Suite 304 – 1,800 sf, former jewelry retail

• Suite 307 – 1,200 sf, ideal for wellness or yoga

• Suite 201 – 3,350 sf office with private rooms and kitchenette

• For more information about Pompton Plaza at 200 Wanaque Ave visit LoopNet

Directions & Parking

Address: 200 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442
Free parking is available behind the plaza with elevator access. Easily accessible via NJ Transit bus lines, Route 23, and I-287.

FAQs about 200 Wanaque Ave

What businesses are located at 200 Wanaque Ave?
Escape Room NJ, Rage Room, Hug-a-Mug, Cardinal Athletics, and Kids Rule Parties.

Was ProjectorScreen.com located here?
Yes, ProjectorScreen.com was headquartered at 200 Wanaque Ave but has since relocated to Riverdale, NJ.

Is parking available?
Yes, free parking is provided in the rear of Pompton Plaza.

Can I rent office space at 200 Wanaque Ave?
Yes, multiple suites are available for retail, office, and studio use.

Was Gelman’s located here?

Yes—Gelman’s served as a local department store at this address through the 1970s 

Tax & Property Insights

Property tax information—including bill payment and property assessments—can be found via the Pompton Lakes municipal tax portal, searchable by block and lot number. Local tax payments are due quarterly—February 1, May 1, August 1, and November 1—with a 10-day grace period and escalating interest for late payments.

About Pompton Lakes & the Location

Incorporated in 1895 and settled from the late 17th century, Pompton Lakes is a borough formed around rivers and early industry. The area embodies small-town New Jersey charm—known for its walkable downtown, parks, and natural scenery including Rotary Park, Hershfield Park, Pompton Lake, and Aquatic Park

News about Redevelopment at Pompton Plaza in Pompton Lakes 07442

The last major redevelopment proposal under consideration is the Pompton Plaza project. Initially pitched as a $120-million mixed-use complex with 380 apartments, the proposal was downsized earlier this year after facing criticism from local officials for its size.

More recent talks have revolved around 210 apartments set above 50,000 square feet of commercial space in a street-level plaza. The revisions reduce the height of the building by about 30 feet from a proposed 200 feet, according to Vasken Setrakian, the property owner. They also trimmed the overall bulk of the main residential structure, which would be set back about 170 feet from the curb to limit its visual impact in the downtown area, Setrakian said.

Pompton Plaza has thus far been discussed primarily in town hall by the borough's Redevelopment Agency, an advisory board tasked with making recommendations to the town council and land use boards on projects in the town's redevelopment zones. Rare in small New Jersey towns, such a board may no longer be needed in Pompton Lakes, according to Councilwoman Jennifer Polidori, who has called for a review of the agency's purpose going forward. Given the constraints on future projects created by the wastewater system's capacity, formal redevelopment reviews may be better left to the council and Planning Board, she said.

Contact

200wanaque07442@gmail.com.